Combating Consumerism: A 360-Degree Look Inside Second-Hand Shopping and Selling


During the 1990’s, fast fashion became a buzz phrase within pop culture after an article in the “The New York Times” was published about ZARA’s rapid design production. The article described the manufacturing process that created cheap and plentiful clothing. Fast fashion is driven by consumerism that ultimately leads to harmful outcomes to the environment, which is shown through this immersive experience. 

“I think fashion, as we know, is one of the most globally polluting industries…the most sustainable that you can be is actually just to not shop at all,” said Megan Chen, 22, a creative designer and climate activist at Stanford University.

Her passion for environmental activism inspired her to create “The Urban Garden Initiative,” a nonprofit that focuses on sustainability and gardening education. Chen’s influential work aims to empower others to understand how to live sustainably through urban gardening. She believes that understanding earth-to-table sustainability will help people understand the importance of sustainable clothing as a whole. 

Sustainable fibers are more environmentally friendly in comparison to petroleum-based fibers as they are dependent upon fossil fuels and are non-biodegradable. 

Fast fashion’s effect on the environment includes chemical and microplastic pollution. According to the Center for Biological Diversity, this industry plays a pivotal role within the climate crisis as it includes 10% of carbon dioxide emissions.  

Companies like Goodwill provide affordable price points for customers and offers an easy-to-use sustainable practice. Faliha Gilani, 29, works as a retail cashier at Goodwill in Houston and believes that people will benefit from second hand shopping. 

“Second hand shopping sometimes is saving people a lot more money than first hand shopping just because they might have multiple kids or college students who probably can’t afford very high end expensive stuff right off the bat,” said Gilani. 

Thrifting preserves the life cycle of clothing, which helps reduce pollution and waste, ultimately benefiting the climate as a whole. By thrifting, customers can also showcase their individuality through self expression. 

“I’ve been just starting to get into customizing and thrift-flipping a lot of the pieces I have that I don’t get to wear as much, and that’s also a really cool way to make clothes feel a bit more individual and me,” said Chen. 

The gentrification of thrifting has become a visible trend within the last decade. Noha Vinoya, 24, a Ph.D. student in communication at Stanford has 10 years of experience within the vintage retail industry. Vinoya sells clothes on Depop, which is an app that allows users to sell or buy unique vintage clothing items. 

“One other point of contention that a lot of resellers get is ‘you’re taking away clothes from those who actually need it,” said Vinoya. “I think that point of waste is really important because if these clothes don’t get purchased, they just end up going to landfills anyway.”

Resellers typically source from places like Goodwill, but not everything gets sold which ultimately leads the clothes to go to either a Goodwill auction, a 99 cents store or abroad. 

Kathy Walsh who works at SMART, a textile recycling organization said her company sells to international markets. According to Walsh, 5% of all donations eventually end up in landfills.

While some argue that fast fashion’s affordability benefits consumers, its long term effects on climate change outweighs its advantages.

“At the end of the day, I think you shouldn’t forget that one of your major motives for thrifting should be about sustainability and not necessarily about profit margining,” said Vinoya.

Authors

  • Sana Dadani

    Sana holds a bachelor’s degree in broadcast journalism and psychology from New York University. While at NYU, she interned at CNN, MSNBC and KPRC2, and reported as a foreign correspondent when studying abroad in Germany, Australia, Ghana and Cuba. Her coverage on the Ghanaian economy’s dependence on women-owned, open-air market stalls was awarded the Edgar Wilson Nye Prize for outstanding student journalism. Before coming to Stanford, she produced local news throughout the COVID-19 pandemic, protests in the wake of George Floyd’s death and the 2020 election season in her hometown, Houston, Texas, on digital platforms for ABC13 KTRK-TV. She also co-hosted newscast segments on online trends and won an Investigative Reporters and Editors fellowship for showing promise in early-career watchdog reporting. She then wrote about global events for theSkimm and covered Texas for Hearst Newspapers. At Stanford, she wants to use data, investigative skills and programming to uncover mental health and disability-related stories, among other underreported issues.

  • Michaela Herbst

    Michaela Herbst is a University of Colorado Boulder graduate with a B.A. in journalism and minor in political science. She was previously a Carnegie-Knight News21 Fellow at the Walter Cronkite School of Journalism. Michaela is an award-winning journalist for her reporting on “America After Roe.” She was recognized by the RFK Human Rights Foundation as a two-time recipient of the Kennedy Human Rights Award for Journalism. Michaela is also a three-time EPPY, two-time Telly and Webby award recipient. She was honored by the Society of Professional Journalists with the Mark of Excellence Award. Throughout her undergraduate career Michaela held leadership positions for TEDxCU, The Bold, CU Honors Journal, Z2 Entertainment and the CU Independent. She recently served as a Democracy Fellow for Congressmen Jason Crow and Jamie Raskin. She is passionate about reporting on women’s rights, climate change and the arts. Michaela is excited to pursue her graduate studies in journalism at Stanford University.

  • Malia Cortez

    Malia Cortez is a creative writer and fintech marketer from Orange County, California. She studied communication as an undergraduate at Stanford University, and she is currently pursuing her M.A. in Communication on the Media Studies track. While her day-to-day academics revolve around technological innovation and its impact on interpersonal relationships and the self, Malia is also broadly interested in learning about different cultures via travel, art, food, and connection with others. She aspires to continue storytelling—in various forms and mediums—as she enjoys how life unfolds.

Scroll to Top